Posts Tagged ‘Discovery’

The child custody interrogatory that often reveals more than it should

It’s typically hard to get useful information from child custody interrogatories.  One question that often reveals more than it should is “Is there anything about the opposing party that renders him [her] unfit to have sole physical custody of the children? If so, describe with specificity this unfitness.” The gap between being a fit parent [...]

Stipulating to family court discovery

Unlike circuit court, there in no automatic discovery in South Carolina’s family court.  See Rule 25, SCFCR.  Most of the time, discovery is ordered at the first temporary hearing.  Often parties (well, the parties’ attorneys) wish to engage in discovery without having a temporary hearing or prior to a temporary hearing.  Other times, the temporary order [...]

Disloyal collegiality in the prosecution and non prosecution of motions to compel

South Carolina attorneys are expected to be collegial.  Part of that collegiality is a reluctance to file motions to compel discovery responses and a frequent acceptance of discovery responses that are incomplete or evasive.  Another part of that collegiality is a general understanding that a demand for fees as part of a motion to compel [...]

Verifying interrogatory answers

I prosecuted a motion to compel recently against an experienced attorney.  One of the things I wanted his client compelled to do was verify the answers to my client’s interrogatories.  At the hearing the opposing attorney reported that, until he received my motion to compel, he was unaware of the requirement that interrogatory answers be [...]

“Shotgunning” motions to compel discovery

While the rules of civil procedure don’t create a distinction, there are really two types of motions to compel discovery.  The first type of motion to compel seeks to compel a party that hasn’t answered discovery to answer discovery.  See SCRCP 37(a)(2).  The second type of motion to compel is based on SCRCP 37(a)(3), which [...]

Discovery in family court: shotgun or rifle approach?

Many of these blogs are inspired by young attorneys I am informally mentoring.  This one was inspired by a query as to the sort of discovery I issue in a family law case.  After seventeen years of practice, I still lack a completely satisfactory answer to that question. I have at least five goals in [...]

A “shot across the bow”: issuing discovery as a method of encouraging settlement

Quite often in my family law cases I will issue written discovery along with a settlement proposal. This is a strategy I see few other attorneys employ and the combination typically confuses my clients. “Why are we issuing discovery,” they will ask, “if our goal is settlement?” A reasonable question deserves a response, so here’s [...]

When to file a contested marital dissolution action before negotiating and when not to request a temporary hearing when filing a contested family court case

It is my experience that most family law attorneys in South Carolina reflexively file a motion for temporary relief when filing a contested family court action or fail to file a marital dissolution action when they hope to negotiate a separation agreement.  Yet I know of two good reasons (there may be others) to file [...]