Burke v. City of Charleston, 139 F.3d 401 (4th Cir 1998), is a published opinion from March 1998 from the Fourth Circuit of the United States Court of Appeals.   It vacated the District Court opinion in Burke v. City of Charleston, 893 F.Supp. 589 (1995). Mr. Burke was a painter who utilized a pop art style.   With the tenant’s permission, he painted a mural on the wall of a commercial building in Charleston’s historic district.  The City of Charleston ordered that his mural be covered up, claiming that it was not historically or architecturally appropriate for downtown Charleston.

Mr. Forman was co-counsel for Mr. Burke in a lawsuit he then brought in Federal District Court against the City of Charleston.  His lawsuit alleged that the city violated his right to free expression by ordering that the mural be covered up.  The city argued that its decision to order the mural covered was a reasonable “time, place or manner” restriction on Burke’s right to free expression.  At trial the lower court decided that the city did not violate Burke’s first amendment right to free expression by ordering his mural covered up and we appealed.  Mr. Forman assisted in the briefing but did not argue the appeal, which was primarily handled by attorneys from The Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression.

The Fourth Circuit, in a 2-1 decision, ruled that Burke lacked the right to bring the lawsuit because he did not own the mural at issue.  It was a heartbreaking decision.  I sometimes reflect upon the final sentence of Judge Wilkinson’s dissenting opinion: “Under the majority rule, if the state boarded up the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, Michelangelo could not contest the action in court.”

Put Mr. Forman’s experience, knowledge, and dedication to your service for any of your South Carolina family law needs.

Recent Blog Posts

De Facto Custodian rights are more valuable than Grandparent Rights

Given the phone calls I receive from prospective clients, it appears that many more folks are aware of the concept of grandparent rights

[ + ] Read More

Supreme Court reverses Court of Appeals determination that same-sex, common-law marriage could not exist prior to 2014

The November 10, 2021, Supreme Court opinion in Swicegood v. Thompson remedies the obvious error in the Court of Appeals decision in Swicegood

[ + ] Read More

Pitfalls in cooperating with DSS child abuse investigations

Parents routinely contact me when they are in the midst of a DSS investigation into their potential abuse or neglect of their child.

[ + ] Read More