Posts Tagged ‘South Carolina Court of Appeals’

Unpublished Court of Appeals opinion undefinitively answers one of my family court questions

The June 25, 2014 unpublished Court of Appeals opinion in Katzburg v. Katzburg undefinitively answers one of my long-standing family court questions. I was retained by Mr. Katzburg after he was incarcerated by the family court for failing to comply with a New Jersey divorce decree that had been turned into a money judgment and […]

Court of Appeals rules prevailing party shouldn’t have to pay the other side’s attorney’s fees

The June 4, 2014 Court of Appeals opinion in Brown v. Brown reversed a $5,000 attorney fee award the family court made to Mother despite Father prevailing on the contested issue of which child support worksheet to use. The primary issues at trial were the number of overnights Father was spending with the children and […]

Court of Appeals slightly modifies prior published opinion of Teeter v. Teeter

On May 21, 2014 the Court of Appeals slightly modified its prior published opinion in the case of Teeter v. Teeter.  As near as I can tell the only difference is that, rather than simply awarding Husband an additional $31,751.95 in equitable distribution, it remanded the matter back “to the family court to determine how the […]

Court of Appeals finds adultery by both spouses and changes ground for divorce

In the extremely odd May 14, 2014 opinion of Mick-Skaggs v. Skaggs, the South Carolina Court of Appeals modified the grounds for divorce from one year’s separation to mutual adultery but otherwise left the family court’s order intact. At trial both parties alleged adultery against the other and Wife sought alimony. The trial court denied both […]

Court of Appeals reverses family court determination that prenuptial agreement was unconscionable on equitable distribution

The April 16, 2014 Court of Appeals opinion in Hudson v. Hudson, 408 S.C. 76, 757 S.E.2d 727 (Ct. App. 2014), reversed the family court’s determination that the parties’ prenuptial agreement was unconscionable on the issue of the equitable distribution of Husband’s pre-marital businesses. The prenuptial agreement included a mutual waiver of alimony, as well as a […]

Court of Appeals affirms custody determination despite claim of improper guardian investigation

The April 2, 2014 Court of Appeals opinion in Simcox-Adams v. Adams affirmed the family court’s award of custody to Husband despite Wife’s challenge to the guardian ad litem’s investigation and report.  It also affirmed the family court’s finding that Wife’s inheritance was transmuted into marital property. Wife raised a number of issues regarding the […]

Court of Appeals finds prenuptial agreement only partially limited family court’s jurisdiction

The March 26, 2014 Court of Appeals opinion in Meehan v. Meehan, 407 S.C. 471, 756 S.E.2d 398 (Ct. App. 2014) determined that the Meehans’ prenuptial divested the family court of jurisdiction for some issues but not the issue of attorney’s fees as it related to child custody and support. Prior to their marriage, the Meehans entered […]

Unpublished Court of Appeals opinion reflects South Carolina’s continuing antiquated view of gender and alimony

South Carolina family law’s approach to alimony continues to reflect an antiquated view of gender roles.  South Carolina is the only state in which a spouse’s adultery will bar alimony–a punishment for “bad” spouses, typically “bad” wives.  Yet, although the alimony statute is gender neutral, I rarely see the family courts awarding husbands alimony–even when […]