Posts Tagged ‘South Carolina Court of Appeals’

Court of Appeals reverses termination of parental rights as not in child’s best interests

The May 3, 2013 Court of Appeals opinion in SCDSS v. Cameron N. F. L. (dig those initials) reversed the termination of parental rights (TPR) of a nine year old special needs child because it found such termination was not in the child’s best interests. Both the factual and evidentiary issues in this case were [...]

Hawkins affirms denial of child support reduction to downsized, underemployed father

The April 17, 2013 Court of Appeals opinion in Hawkins v. Hawkins demonstrates the continued reluctance of the family courts to reduce child support obligations for downsized non-custodial parents. In Hawkins, the parties’ divorce decree specifically allowed child support to be recalculated pursuant to the South Carolina Child Support Guidelines on an annual basis.  In [...]

Pre-trial order settling “personal property” precludes equitable distribution of retirement accounts

I’ve had a few cases in which the issue of what constitutes “personal property” has been the subject of debate.  The understanding of the typical litigant is that such property is the household furnishings–what a homeowner’s policy might consider “contents.”  However, from a purely legal standard, personal property is any property that isn’t real estate. [...]

Court of Appeals finds family court has authority to order federal pensioner to designate particular beneficiary for survivor benefits plan

The March 6, 2013 Court of Appeals opinion in Barber v. Barber, 402 S.C. 96, 738 S.E.2d 845 (Ct. App. 2013), clarifies a narrow but frequently occurring equitable distribution issue: can the family court order a federal pensioner to designate a particular beneficiary for his or her survivor benefits plan?  The Court of Appeals held it [...]

The difficulty of bringing tort claims against the Department of Social Services

Last week a colleague of mine told me a story of attending a Charleston Riverdogs (the local minor league baseball team) game in which a staff attorney for the abuse and neglect section of the Charleston County Department of Social Services was throwing out the first pitch.  The announcer stated the honoree’s profession, whereupon the [...]

What becomes of a transmuted waterfront lot?

In my almost four years of blogging about every reported South Carolina appellate decision from family court and over fifteen years of handling family law appeals, I can discern a few clear patterns on when the appellate courts will reverse an equitable distribution award.  Math errors and clear mistakes of law will always lead to [...]

Court of Appeals holds alimony agreement not ambiguous

In the December 28, 2012 opinion in Gaffney v. Gaffney, 401 S.C. 216, 736 S.E.2d 683 (Ct. App. 2012), the South Carolina Court of Appeals reversed the family court’s determination that the parties’ Marital Separation Agreement (MSA)was ambiguous and terminated husband’s alimony obligation completely. The parties were divorced in 2009.  Their divorce decree approved an MSA [...]

Court of Appeals rejects further alimony reduction when family court determines husband’s income hadn’t decreased

In the December 12, 2012 opinion of King v. King, 400 S.C. 611, 735 S.E.2d 551 (Ct. App. 2012), the Court of Appeals affirmed the family court’s decision to deny Husband’s request to further reduce his alimony. At the time of the parties’ divorce in 1999, Husband had a yearly base salary of $300,000 as chief [...]