Posted Sunday, February 12th, 2012 by Gregory Forman

The parade of human misery passing by judges dealing with marital disputes must lead many to despair.  The rare tales of a judge doing something creative to resolve these disputes are often amusing.  Consider the Florida judge who finding a husband’s domestic violence towards his wife to be “very, very minor,” sentenced him to take his wife on a date.  The requirements of the date included buying her flowers, dining at Red Lobster, and then taking her bowling.

Red Lobster?  Bowling?  Really?  Obviously I’ve taken no census on the number of wives I’ve encountered in my decades of family law practice who would be appeased by Red Lobster and bowling but I doubt it’s many.

So my question for my lady readers: is this judge’s sentence justice or just more domestic abuse in another form?  Either way, I’ve got new plans for Valentine’s Day.

Filed under

(5) Comments

MJ Goodwin

February 12, 2012 at 5:05 pm

Have you seen the movie "Beer for My Horses"? In that classic flick, a gentleman (I use the term in the loosest sense), reconciles with his wife by taking her out for "catfish and hushpuppies". I had not considered that they were going to Red Lobster. But I suppose that is possible. When I first moved to Anderson, Red Lobster was one of the fanciest restaurants here. It was also referred to as "The Red Lobster." So I guess it is all relative. From my perspective, if I didn't have to cook it, it's pretty good.

Allison J. LaMantia

February 12, 2012 at 7:56 pm

I think it would have been more effective if the judge had sentenced him to 10 loads of laundry, a week's worth of cooking, a whole house cleaning, child care for 2 girls' nights out, and an hour long foot massage. Dinner at Red Lobster is adding insult to the wife's injury, no?

David Pollock

February 12, 2012 at 10:04 pm

Flowers yes. Red Lobster no. Bowling definitely not. Sounds like cruel and unusual punishment.

MJ Goodwin

February 13, 2012 at 8:23 am

I should add that I personally do not care for bowling. And a man is never hotter than when he is vacuuming or loading the dishwasher.

Jenny Moser

February 13, 2012 at 9:24 am

While I think the judge was taking a huge risk by sentencing the parties to time together following a domestic violence charge, I cannot imagine how Red Lobster could make anything better for this couple. I have to say, however, I was out quite a bit with my kids this past weekend, and almost everywhere we went, I saw dads out with their kids eating, going to movies, etc. No moms in sight (except me, of course). I agree with Allison that sometimes the best Valentine's Day gift a father can give a mother is time to unwind or go hang with her girlfriends without kids in tow.

Leave a Reply

Contact

Schedule a Consultation

If you are looking to schedule a consultation or retain Mr. Forman please fill out this form and he will get back to you promptly.

Mr. Forman currently charges $500.00 for initial consultations, which last one-hour. This consult fee is due at the time the consult is scheduled and is non-refundable. You are welcome to use this link to pay the consult fee and Mr. Forman will get back to you about scheduling the consult.

Address
Please let us know what's on your mind. Have a question for us? Ask away.